If you couldn't tell, I really didn't like this article. I don't think it defended vegetarianism very well and I think it did a terrible job of trying to equate patriarchy with meat eating. I will admit that there may be some small similarities between meat eating and male dominance, but vegetarianism alone is clearly not going to overthrow the patriarchy. It is actually pretty foolish to presume that there is any kind of real correlation between meat eating and patriarchy or vegetarianism and matriarchy. Besides that, becoming a vegetarian does not offer any solution to the "problem" of male dominance. Furthermore, women are not usually looked upon as mere “possessions” any more,
they are not solely sex objects and they are not the only ones who are sexually
objectified, and a lot of women eat meat. Women can be in a relationship or marriage with a man and still retain their individuality. Women are able to do paid work, vote in elections, and receive an education. Women in the Western world have a lot of independence for living in a patriarchy. And although women still have a lot more ground to gain in terms of egalitarianism, you can't simply ignore all that women have accomplished thus far. Women can be vegetarians if they want, but they don't need vegetarianism to challenge the patriarchy.
I agree with pretty much all of your points in the last four posts, but it seems that you addressed only one side of the article. While you did a very good job both separating vegetarianism from feminism, and defining ways to be a good feminist, you didn't really address the issue of whether vegetarianism is morally obligatory or even morally admirable.
ReplyDeleteThat is very true, I did only address one side. I just found it so irritating I couldn't stop talking about it! Personally, I am not a vegetarian and I don't understand a lot about vegetarianism, particularly the pros and cons of it. It is something that I would very much like to learn more about though, so I would love to read anything you have to say about it.
DeleteIt is an interesting subject; if you are really interested in learning more about it, I recommend reading Tom Regan's works. I mostly agree with what he has to say on the subject, but have a few differences which I mentioned here: http://asfcmi2012s.blogspot.com/2012/02/animal-equality.html
Delete